• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Blue Horse Beach Cafe: A Family-Friendly Eatery in Fish Creek, WI

At Blue Horse Beach Cafe, our journey began with a passion for crafting delightful sandwiches and unforgettable brunch experiences. Nestled in the charming town of Fish Creek, WI, we take pride in our casual and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for families and friends alike. Our menu features a variety of options, including vegan delights, ensuring everyone finds something to love. With outdoor seating to soak in the local beauty and amenities like free Wi-Fi and dog-friendly spaces, we invite guests to relax and enjoy. Whether you're stopping by for breakfast, lunch, or a leisurely brunch, Blue Horse Beach Cafe offers a taste of community and culinary joy.

Blue Horse Beach Cafe at a glance

  • Address 4113 Main St Fish Creek, WI 54212 United States
  • Phone (920) 868-1471
  • Restaurant type Sandwich shop , Breakfast restaurant , Coffee shop , Espresso bar , Takeout restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for breakfast , Popular for lunch , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Blue Horse Beach Cafe: Reviews & Ratings

Tracie Hodina Van Pelt
5

Freshly made blended fruit smoothies. The breakfast sandwich with house made sausage and biscuits....yes, please! We were lucky to snag a seat overlooking the water.

Cam W
5

Amazing view! Helpful and friendly staff. Clean facilities with lots of seating. Full coffee menu along with baked goods, sandwiches, soups and salads. We had a BLT and chicken curry sandwiches with caramel lattes. All of it was wonderful and we had a very short wait time.

Meesh
5

Whenever I visit Door County, a stop at Blue Horse Beach Cafe in Fish Creek is a must for breakfast or lunch. Their sandwiches are always fresh and delicious, and the bread they use is so good- it's soft, hearty, and the perfect base for their flavorful fillings. One of my favorites is the Curry Chicken Salad sandwich--it's bursting with sweet and spicy flavor. Their soup is great, often with a spicy kick that I love. Blue Horse clearly enjoys experimenting with Indian spices, and it shows in their bold, unique flavors. They also have great coffee; I always treat myself to a vanilla oat milk latte--smooth, creamy, and just the right amount of sweet. Highly recommend- great food & great coffee.

Anna Zoromski-Linde
5

Our usual coffee shop was sold and went here based on the reviews online. They don’t lie. We had coffee, Vanilla Italian soda, coconut cold brew and sunrise breakfast sandwich, chocolate chip biscuit and the jalapeño egg sandwich. There was a line out the door but we were able to sit down immediately. Coffee was done in less than 5 as was the food. We had a great experience and food was fresh and prepared to high standards. Loved listening to the kitchen crew yell out the different names and sayings too. Thanks Blue Horse!

Carrie
5

Incredible chorizo breakfast burrito! And I loved the house hot sauce. The man running the cash register was awesome. There was a lot of seating at the restaurant but we took our food across the street to eat by the water. A 5 minute wait in the line and 15 minute wait for food at 10:30 am on a summer Friday.

Ava Kolb
5

Great spot to grab a quick bite! Service was friendly and fast, food took a bit but was worth the wait. There is a good seating selection between tables indoors near the windows and outdoor seating in the back of house. Coffee wise, their iced mochas were pretty chocolate-y but delicious!

Sharon Luo
5

We first found Blue Horse Beach Café last fall on a Door County foliage trip and loved it, so we had to return. It's always nice sitting in the front room with a water view, enjoying a coffee and quick breakfast. The food and drinks are great, the staff is friendly, and the cozy vibe has made this one of our new favorite spots in Fish Creek.

Robin VandenLangenberg
5

Delicious food! The chef is so fun and friendly, love the atmosphere. I ordered the Jalapeño Egg sandwich and a blended horchata. Both were fantastic!

Location

  • Blue Horse Beach Cafe
    Blue Horse Beach Cafe
    4113 Main St Fish Creek, WI 54212 United States Hotline: (920) 868-1471

Welcome to the delightful Blue Horse Beach Cafe, a charming oasis located in Fish Creek, Wisconsin. Nestled at 4113 Main St, this casual eatery is a haven for beach lovers and food enthusiasts alike.

At Blue Horse Beach Cafe, you'll discover a menu bursting with flavor. Known for its delectable sandwiches, this spot is ideal for breakfast, brunch, or lunch. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty morning meal or a light afternoon bite, you'll find something to tickle your taste buds.

  • Vegan Options: Catering to diverse dietary needs, the cafe offers a range of vegan dishes that are just as satisfying as their traditional counterparts.
  • Outdoor Seating: Enjoy your meal al fresco while soaking in the vibrant coastal atmosphere.
  • Good for Groups: Whether it's a family outing or a gathering with friends, the cafe provides ample space for everyone to enjoy.
  • Free Wi-Fi: Looking to get some work done? The cafe is a perfect spot for productive mornings and casual work sessions.
  • Dog-Friendly: Bring along your furry companions and savor a meal together.

What makes Blue Horse Beach Cafe truly special is the combination of its friendly ambiance and delicious offerings. The moderate noise level makes it suitable for families and groups, while the casual touristy vibe invites both locals and visitors to relax and indulge. I've personally enjoyed their sandwiches that burst with freshness and flavor—a perfect complement to a day at the beach.

The cafe also accommodates various payment methods including Apple Pay and credit cards, making your visit hassle-free. Plus, with options for takeout and delivery, you can enjoy their culinary delights wherever you please.

So, if you're in the Fish Creek area and longing for a place to satiate your hunger while basking in a cozy beach atmosphere, make your way to Blue Horse Beach Cafe. You won't be disappointed!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Service options
    • Has outdoor seating
    • On-site services available
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards